5 replies to this topic

[microphobe]

Hi,

I published a paper last year in a fairly good journal (impact factor 9). I am having difficulty thinking of another journal that is exactly suited to my work so I'm considering submitting there again this year. Of course I could try to 'spin' it for a more generalized journal but I'm wondering whether it's worth the effort.


It is true that it will look bad on my CV if I publish twice in a row in the same place? (I am a post-doc in academia)

Edited by microphobe, 30 September 2010 - 01:28 AM.

[gebirgsziege]

I do not think so; unless your PI is editor of the journal or someone else of your dept. is very close to the journal, this would look like nepotism. If your work fits well within the scope of the journal and it has a good reputation (supposing from the IF) I would not think there is a problem in publishing there more than once.

microphobe, on 30 September 2010 - 01:28 AM, said:

Hi,

I published a paper last year in a fairly good journal (impact factor 9). I am having difficulty thinking of another journal that is exactly suited to my work so I'm considering submitting there again this year. Of course I could try to 'spin' it for a more generalized journal but I'm wondering whether it's worth the effort.


It is true that it will look bad on my CV if I publish twice in a row in the same place? (I am a post-doc in academia)

[laurequillo]

I wouldnt mind to publish two or three times in a row in Nature or Science....

Yeah, it is not problem at all

Edited by laurequillo, 30 September 2010 - 04:53 AM.

[pito]

no problem at all...

[Maddie]

Ditto.

IF 9 is pretty cool. If you think your paper has a chance, go for it. I had a colleague who used to tell me to start as high as possible. He said that if your paper gets accepted right away in an average journal, it means that maybe you could have chosen a better journal. I don't know. I guess it depends on several factors, one being: how much in a hurry are you?

[microphobe]

Well, I don't want to end up like your avatar before I get it out there    

Thanks for the advice everyone, I submitted yesterday... now I just have to resist checking the manuscript status every two hours  

Edited by microphobe, 02 November 2010 - 11:31 PM.